*This post contains affiliate links.
Updated on 3/27/25
Store-bought sugar-free creamers in a variety of flavors — ready to pour, no mixing required.
I’ve recently become obsessed with iced coffee, and that sent me on a mission to find the best sugar free coffee creamer that actually tastes good and fits my low-carb lifestyle. My sister suggested almond milk, but let’s be real—that’s not what I was looking for.
Best Sugar-Free Coffee Creamer Ever: Taste-Tested, Store-Bought Favorites You Can Actually Find
What is the best sugar free coffee creamer? The best store-bought sugar-free coffee creamers are Splenda Sugar-Free Sweet Cream Creamer and Coffee Mate Sugar-Free Italian Sweet Cream. These creamers offer the perfect mix of flavor and creaminess without added sugar, and they’re ideal for keto, low-carb, or WW-friendly diets.
🌟 The Hunt for the Best Sugar Free Coffee Creamer
I know I’m late to the iced coffee party, but I’m fully in now — and I drink a LOT. My sister suggested unsweetened almond milk, and I was like…no thanks. That kicked off my mission to find the best sugar-free coffee creamer that I could actually enjoy and keep in stock.
🤔 So Many Choices, So Little Fridge Space
Once I started looking, I couldn’t believe how many sugar-free creamers were out there. But most of the ones on Pinterest are DIY homemade creamers — not my thing. I wanted store-bought only. And preferably something I didn’t have to shake, blend, or make myself at 7AM.
So yes, our fridge became a creamer graveyard. My husband, a non-coffee drinker, could not relate.
⚠️ What About Artificial Sweeteners?
Artificial sweeteners get a bad rap, but listen—if you’re trying to keep sugar low and WW points even lower, they are your best friend.
For keto folks, creamers made with monk fruit or sugar alcohols are amazing because they won’t spike blood sugar. Heavy cream and heavy whipping cream are also keto favorites thanks to their low carb content.
If you’re curious about how artificial sweeteners stack up health-wise, the Mayo Clinic breaks it all down — from safety to side effects. For anyone watching sugar intake on keto, low-carb, or WW, it’s worth understanding the differences between sugar substitutes.
🥛 Dairy-Free & Low-Cal Options
If you want to cut fat and calories but still want something creamy:
- Nonfat milk adds creaminess without the extra fat
- Coconut milk is naturally sweet and dairy-free
- Oat milk (like Califia Farms) is a smooth, neutral option
These are great if you’re dairy-free, but I found most of them too thin to stand up to strong iced coffee.
If you’re more of a cold drink fan, my Peach Cobbler Frappuccino is a must-try. Sweet, creamy, and totally WW and keto-adaptable!
☕️ The Great Taste Test Begins
Store-bought creamer being poured into coffee — smooth, easy, and ready to enjoy.
I went out with a list and taste-tested every sugar-free creamer I could find. My mission? Find something with:
- Good flavor
- Creaminess
- Low calories
- Easy to store (bonus if shelf-stable!)
Here were the top contenders:
- Starbucks Zero Hazelnut Latte Creamer – Creamy, 20 calories per tbsp, expensive but delish
- Starbucks Zero Caramel Macchiato Creamer – Same as above, harder to find
- Splenda Sugar Free Sweet Cream Creamer – Shelf-stable, creamy, my son loved it in oatmeal
- Coffee Mate Sugar Free Italian Sweet Cream – Very similar to Splenda, delicious
- Coffee Mate Sugar Free Cinnamon Roll – Weird in coffee, better in tea
- International Delight Sugar Free Caramel – Good flavor, a bit thin, super affordable
And the flops:
- Natural Bliss Zero Sugar Almond & Coconut – Thin, watery, nope
- Leaner Creamer – Slightly better than Bliss, still too thin, overpriced
📊 Top Sugar-Free Creamers You Can Buy
| Brand | Flavor | Calories/Tbsp | Creaminess | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Splenda Sugar Free Sweet Cream | Sweet Cream | 15 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Shelf-stable, creamy, crowd-pleaser |
| Coffee Mate Sugar Free Italian | Italian Sweet Cream | 15 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Super creamy, easy to find |
| Starbucks Zero | Hazelnut, Caramel Macchiato | 20 | ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ | Tastes great, pricey |
| Coffee Mate Cinnamon Roll | Cinnamon Roll | 15 | ⭐⭐⭐ | Better in tea |
| International Delight Sugar Free | Caramel | 20 | ⭐⭐⭐ | Budget pick, a bit thin |
🌿 Store-Bought > Homemade (Let’s Be Honest)
I tested these creamers in both black coffee and iced coffee. They’re store-bought, easy to find, and don’t require any prep.
Almond milk creamers? Not my favorite — too thin. But if you’re into nut milks, they can be lower in fat and calories.
❓Sugar-Free Coffee Creamer FAQs: What You Need to Know
What is the healthiest sugar-free coffee creamer?
The healthiest sugar-free coffee creamer depends on your needs. For keto and low-carb diets, look for creamers made with monk fruit or sugar alcohols. If you’re watching WW points, Coffee Mate Sugar-Free Italian Sweet Cream and Splenda Sugar-Free Sweet Cream Creamer are low in calories and WW-friendly.
Do any sugar-free creamers actually taste good?
Yes! After taste-testing, top picks like Splenda Sugar-Free Sweet Cream and Starbucks Zero Hazelnut Creamer stood out for flavor and creaminess — without that weird aftertaste.
What’s the best sugar-free creamer for iced coffee?
Shelf-stable creamers like Splenda’s or Starbucks Zero Caramel Macchiato perform well in iced coffee because they stay creamy and mix easily, even when cold.
Are oat milk and almond milk creamers better than dairy?
Oat and almond milk creamers are great for dairy-free diets, but many tend to be thinner. If you like a rich, creamy cup, sugar-free dairy-based creamers might hold up better.
Where can I buy these sugar-free creamers?
Most of the creamers mentioned are available at major grocery stores like Walmart and Target, or online through Amazon. Just be sure to check labels — not all are truly sugar-free!
🏆 So What’s the Best Sugar-Free Coffee Creamer?
Two winners:
Splenda Sugar Free Sweet Cream Creamer — creamy, delicious, shelf-stable, low-cal, and easy to stockpile. My favorite.
Coffee Mate Sugar Free Italian Sweet Cream — equally creamy and smooth, slightly easier to find locally.
If you’re drinking coffee daily (like me), buy it in bulk, hide it in the garage, and tell your husband it’s a vitamin. 🤦♀️
And if you love a cozy cup of coffee, don’t miss my Better Than Starbucks Pumpkin Spice Latte — it’s sugar-free, WW-friendly, and made for fall vibes.
Need a sweet pairing for your morning coffee? Check out my 8 Insanely Delicious Baked Donuts You Won’t Believe Are Healthy – they’re low in points and full of flavor!
🛒 Don’t forget to save this post! Whether you’re team iced coffee or hot, these store-bought sugar-free creamers are game-changers. Pin now — thank yourself later!
PIN FOR LATER
